Skip to main content

Why do Samsung’s AR Emoji suck compared to Apple’s Animoji?

  • The Samsung AR Emoji got a lot of press when the company announced the feature, but reactions have been lukewarm at best.
  • AR Emoji aren't as good as Apple's Animoji due to a lack of camera sensors and Samsung's thoughts on your attention span.
  • Future AR Emoji programs will inevitably get better, but without better hardware they'll never match Animoji,

When Samsung revealed that the Samsung Galaxy S9 would feature animated Emoji characters, the world groaned. Not only is the idea pretty trite in comparison to the other innovations Samsung could have focused on with its latest flagship, but it was a clear imitation of Apple's recently announced Animoji feature for the iPhone X.

Still, the idea of animating an Emoji character using your own facial features is not altogether bad, and the function received a lot of initial press.

Editor's Pick
related article

Samsung Galaxy S9 and S9 Plus review: Top-notch notch-less

Samsung doesn't need to revolutionize the smartphone industry in 2018 — it needs to iterate on all the hard work it did with the Galaxy S8 line last year. But with the added pressure of …

However, once people got ahold of the device and started playing around with AR Emoji, it was a world of disappointment. Our own review of the Galaxy S9 called AR Emoji "far from a polished product" and "pretty creepy."

Why do AR Emoji suck so much, especially since Apple's Animojis are so much better?

The answer is two-fold: the under-powered selfie camera on the Galaxy S9 and Samsung's opinion on the length of your attention span.

samsung galaxy s9 review

AR Emoji's Hollywood pedigree

According to a new CNET article, Samsung obtained the technology to create AR Emoji from a two-year-old startup called Loom.ai. The startup's resume is quite impressive, with a clients list featuring Lucasfilm, DreamWorks, and Disney. The CTO and principal engineer of Loom.ai are each Oscar-winners in technical categories.

That kind of Hollywood pedigree is likely what made Loom.ai stand out to Samsung when it was searching for an Animoji competitor. Truth be told, the way AR Emoji work is not unlike how motion-capture works in major Hollywood films; it's just incredibly watered down.

Editor's Pick
related article

AR Emoji vs Animoji: The differences explained

The Galaxy S9 is here and like the rumors suggested, Samsung has taken a leaf out of Apple's book with its new AR Emoji feature. The iPhone X bought Animoji last year and Samsung's comparative …

If you were to star in a major blockbuster as a mo-cap character, you would be filmed and photographed on million-dollar equipment with special makeup and clothing to make your character as lifelike as possible. The way AR Emoji (and Animoji) work is to use those same methods in an amateur way.

You can't make a great AR Emoji without a great set of sensors that the Galaxy S9 doesn't have.

Therefore, the difference in quality between the Samsung AR Emoji and the Apple Animoji partially comes down to hardware. To be blunt, the front-facing sensors on the iPhone X outrank the sensors on the Galaxy S9 on every level.

With the iPhone X and its facial scanning features, the phone can create a 3D rendering of your face. That rendering can then be molded into an Animoji, creating an adequate facsimile of you.

With the Galaxy S9 and its basic sensors, you can only create a 2D image of your face. That's why AR Emoji don't look much like the person and instead somewhat generic.

Samsung doesn't think you can wait a few minutes

Going back to starring as a mo-cap character in a Hollywood movie, to create your character you would be shooting for hours just to get your basic facial features down. But with AR Emoji, the processing happens within seconds.

Editor's Pick
related article

Samsung Galaxy S9 vs iPhone X: Camera shootout

https://youtu.be/578FTcGMoSE The Samsung Galaxy S9 has hit the streets and now everyone is trying to figure out if it lives up to all the hype. No matter which Android phone comes out, its biggest competitor is …

That's because Samsung doesn't think you'll want to sit around for a few minutes to create your AR Emoji. If Samsung designed the process differently, the current core code that creates AR Emoji is capable of making more true-to-life images of your face; it would just take minutes instead of seconds. Samsung figured that you'd rather have a crappy AR Emoji in a few seconds than a decent AR Emoji in a few minutes.

If Samsung simply gave the AR Emoji software more time to work, AR Emoji could be so much better.

Thanks for the vote of confidence, Samsung.

The idea of rendering your face and facial movements onto an animated character is a new one, and no one should expect the first two tries to get it perfect. It's likely that future competitors and new iterations of AR Emoji and Animoji will be more realistic and overall better than what we have now.

But if you wanted to know why AR Emoji suck compared to Animoji, now you know.

NEXT: Samsung design patent reveals a notch and we can already hear the screams


#Google #Android #Smartphones #OS #News @ndrdnws #ndrdnws #AndroidNews

Advertisement

Most Popular:

Where to buy phones in India

Buying a new smartphone can be a difficult decision, as there are seemingly being endless options that cover the specifications, features, and price spectrums.The good news is that in India you don't have to worry about network carrier contracts and locked devices like in the US. This makes it much easier to choose where to buy a phone. On the flip side, since you have to pay the full price for a neere w device, whyou buy it from could be the difference between paying the MRP (maximum retail price) or enjoying a nice discount.What are the best places to buy phones from in India? Let's take a look!E-commerce storesFlipkartHindustan TimesFlipkart was the OG e-commerce website in India, starting back in 2007 as an online bookstore. Various acquisitions and continuous expansion since its humble beginnings have made Flipkart one of the go-to online stores in India for everything like clothes, shoes, books, furniture, electronics, and a whole lot more.Flipkart also remains one of th…

Samsung Galaxy S9, Galaxy S9+ 128GB versions launched in India, price starts at Rs 61900 #Google #Android #News #Smartphone #APK

Samsung is bringing the 128GB version of its flagship Galaxy S9 and Galaxy S9+ phones to India. The Galaxy S9 and Galaxy S9+ 128GB version will be available for buying from across online and offline stores at Rs 61,900 and Rs 68,900 respectively, Samsung announced on Tuesday. Both the phones will be available in three colours: Midnight Black, Coral Blue and Lilac Purple.Previously Samsung had launched only the 64GB and the 256GB versions of the Galaxy S9 and Galaxy S9+ phones in India. While the 64GB version of the Galaxy S9 sells in India at Rs 57,900, the top-end 256GB version of the phone is available for Rs 65,900. The Galaxy S9+ meanwhile starts at Rs 64,900 for the 64GB version, going all the way to Rs 72,900 for the top-end 256GB version.While the 64GB version of the Galaxy S9 and Galaxy S9+ is available for buying from select offline stores and online via Samsung Shop and Flipkart, the 256GB version of the phones is available from Reliance Digital stores, Samsung exclusive sto…

Vivo V9 FAQ #Google #Android #News #Smartphone #APK

Vivo recently unveiled the V9 in India. The handset is currently on pre-order and goes on sale in the country from early next month. What sets the Vivo V9 apart from other handsets is its design. The front of the handset features a bezel-less design including a notch at the top which makes it look very similar to the iPhone X.Vivo proudly boasts that the V9 has a screen-to-body ratio of 90 percent which makes it as compact as a 5.5-inch smartphone despite coming with a 6.3-inch display. While significantly more expensive, the Vivo V9 does compete with Xiaomi's excellent Redmi Note 5 Pro in many ways.If you are smitten by the Vivo V9 and plan on buying one, below is our FAQ surrounding the handset which answers all the questions you might have about the device.Q) What are the full specifications of the Vivo V9? A) The full specs of the Vivo V9 are as follows:Dimensions: 154.81 x 75.03 x 7.89 mmWeight: 150gDisplay: 6.3-inch 19:9 aspect ratio, FHD+ (2280 x 1080), 2.5D Gorilla GlassCh…

Jio to Deploy Massive MIMO Pre-5G Networks at IPL 2018 Stadiums in Delhi, Mumbai

Reliance Jio this week announced that the telecom giant would be deploying pre-5G/ 4G advanced Massive MIMO in Mumbai and Delhi to offer high speed Internet access during IPL 2018.
#Google #Android #Smartphones #OS #News @ndrdnws #ndrdnws #AndroidNews

9to5Toys Lunch Break: Nest Thermostat E $123, Laptop Backpack $10, JBL Charge 2+ Bluetooth Speaker $60, more

Keep up with the best gear and deals on the web by signing up for the 9to5Toys Newsletter. Also, be sure to check us out on: TwitterRSS FeedFacebookGoogle+ and Safari push notifications.Everyone can use an Echo Dot: Just $50! 9to5Toys Lunch Break delivers the best deals every day of the week at 12:30PM EST. This includes price drops on all sorts of Apple products from iPad to MacBook and everything in between, as well as HomeKit gear, accessories of all kinds and so much more.You'll also find our daily coverage of the coolest new gear and gadgets from across the internet along with our New Toy of the Day, product reviews, giveaways and app sales. Head below for today's top deals and most interesting new products in the world of tech and beyond…TODAY'S CAN'T MISS DEALS:Nest's lower-priced Thermostat E drops to $123 shipped, down from $169JBL's Charge 2+ Bluetooth speaker is splashproof, more at $60 (Refurb, Orig. $150)Best Sellers 001: This isn't the Ai…